A delegation from the Afghan Taliban met Tuesday with European Union staff in Brussels for closed-door talks that focused on diplomatic services and “dignified returns” of Afghans to the isolated and war-ravaged nation, said a Taliban official.
Afghans make up one of the largest groups of migrants seeking asylum in the European Union, but a growing number of governments in the 27-nation bloc want to speed up and increase deportations for those whose claims are rejected or who commit crimes in their host countries.
“This was a historic visit as first time ever that delegation from Islamic Emirate visited the E.U. and held talks with member states in Brussels,” said Abdul Qahar Balkhi, a spokesperson for the Taliban Ministry of Foreign Affairs who led the delegation of five figures.
Balkhi also said they spoke about “restarting broad-range consular services for Afghans in E.U. zone, including need for trust-building measures, consular presence and dignified return process.”
The meeting was held in an undisclosed location in the Belgian capital, which is also the headquarters of the E.U. itself and the NATO military alliance.
Rights groups say meeting could endanger Afghans in and out of Europe
Afghan authorities have imposed draconian restrictions on rights, particularly for women and girls, since the Taliban seized power in the country in 2021 in the wake of the chaotic withdrawal of U.S.-led forces.
Rights groups said Tuesday’s meeting undercuts the E.U.’s human rights obligations and could endanger people in Europe and Afghanistan.
“Any engagement with the Taliban needs to prioritize protecting human rights and accountability — not deporting people to danger there,” said Fereshta Abbasi, a researcher at Human Rights Watch. “E.U. countries are undermining their credibility by condemning Taliban abuses and pursuing accountability on one hand, while cooperating with the Taliban to forcibly return Afghans on the other.”
With not a single E.U. nation recognizing the Taliban, the meeting in Brussels symbolizes a small crack in the group’s diplomatic isolation since seizing power five years ago. Most nations around the world — including the entire E.U — cut off diplomatic relations at the time. The Taliban has been quietly expanding its access to diplomatic missions in Europe ever since.
Belgian Foreign Minister Maxime Prévot said that while Belgium doesn’t recognize the Taliban, it would comply with E.U. requests to grant the Taliban visas.
“Belgium cannot confer legitimacy on a regime accused of serious human rights violations,” he said in a statement referring to Belgium’s hosting of the E.U. institutions. “Making a meeting possible in the framework of our host-state policy does not amount to recognition, does not amount to legitimacy, and does not constitute an invitation by the Belgian government.”
Afghan activist and Nobel Peace Prize laureate Malala Yousafzai said Monday that she was “deeply shaken” that the E.U. was talking with the Taliban.
“Europe must not legitimise a regime responsible for one of the worst human rights crises in the world. Any engagement with the Taliban must begin and end with the rights of Afghan women and girls,” she wrote on X.
Members of the Taliban delegation were issued visas after security screening with limited territorial validity, giving them 24 hours in Belgium and no access to other countries in the Schengen border-free travel zone.
Since neither Belgium nor the E.U. officially recognizes the Taliban government, the meeting did not take place inside official buildings or sites belonging to either.
The European Commission has declined repeated requests to provide additional information about the meeting.
The drive to increase deportations from E.U. grows stronger
A spokesperson for the European Commission said that the meeting is in response to pressure from a clear majority of the 27 E.U. member states- 20 of whom signed a letter in October calling for stronger migration policies, including a ramp-up of deportations.
Commission spokesperson Markus Lammert said the Commission had been asked to coordinate technical contacts on returns and that E.U. nations are initially targeting criminals and people deemed a threat by security authorities.
“These are technical-level contacts,” he said. “This does not mean recognition.”
He also said that some E.U. member nations were allowed to meet the Taliban during the meeting, but did not clarify.
While this is the first meeting of the Taliban in the E.U., the first meeting between the two sides was held in Afghanistan in January when the Commission sent a mission to Kabul. It also maintains staff there.
The October letter was drafted in part by Belgian Migration Minister Anneleen Van Bossuyt, who said then that “we have sent a clear and powerful message to the European Commission: we can no longer afford a standstill. It is high time for a firm and joint approach, so that Europe can regain control over migration and security.”
Bossuyt said that across the E.U., only 2% of the 22,870 Afghans told to return had done so.
Afghanistan faces an increasingly dire situation
Afghanistan has been dealing with the return of about 3 million Afghans from Pakistan and Iran in the past year alone, all of whom have pretty much been forcibly repatriated from those two countries, exacerbating a humanitarian disaster in Afghanistan, already reeling from food and economic crises, including biting sanctions.
Afghan Taliban authorities have imposed draconian restrictions on women and girls, including bans on education beyond primary school and on working in all but very few professions, as well as strict regulations on what women are allowed to wear in public.
“The desperate scenes of people — including E.U. staff — fleeing Afghanistan are a recent memory. It is unconscionable that the E.U. would now try and deport people to Afghanistan, which has only become more dangerous in the meantime,” said Eve Geddie, Director of Amnesty International’s European Institutions Office.
Facing political pressure to toughen migration policies across the 27-nation bloc, the E.U. has recently passed deep reforms to its collective rules aiming to ramp up deportations - including allowing the setting up of so-called “return hubs,” increased domestic surveillance capabilities, tighter border controls, and engagement with the Taliban government, which it does not recognize because of human rights abuse allegations.
With Afghanistan facing food shortages and economic collapse, the Taliban government is in need of humanitarian aid and hopes to lessen its international economic and political isolation.
