Three Māori lawmakers in New Zealand received record suspensions of up to three weeks Thursday over a protest haka they performed against a contentious bill in Parliament last year.
The lawmakers drew global attention in November when they performed the haka, a ceremonial chanting dance of defiance that is a cherished cultural symbol of New Zealand. They were protesting legislation that would have reinterpreted the country’s 184-year-old founding document, a treaty that was signed between colonial British rulers and Indigenous Māori.
A parliamentary committee found the three lawmakers in contempt of parliament last month and recommended that they be suspended for up to three weeks “for acting in a manner that could have the effect of intimidating a member of the House.”
Debbie Ngarewa-Packer and Rawiri Waititi, co-leaders of Te Pāti Māori, the Māori party, which holds six of Parliament’s 123 seats, were suspended for three weeks each.
Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke, who at 22 is New Zealand’s youngest legislator, was suspended for one week on the recommendation of the committee, which said in its report that she had demonstrated “some level of contrition” in her written statement.
The votes were 68-55 against Maipi-Clarke, 68-54 against Ngarewa-Packer and 68-53 against Waititi, all of whom were suspended immediately.
Waititi told reporters after the votes that he and his colleagues would “continue to be the voices our people expect us to be.”
“They are demonizing haka,” he said of the lawmakers who voted for the suspensions. “They are making us out to be violent, to be disruptive, and our people have heard that for a long, long time.”
It is rare for New Zealand lawmakers to receive such suspensions, which are unpaid. The longest anyone had previously been suspended was three days.
The opposition Labour Party, as well as the Green Party, criticized the suspensions as disproportionate, with the Labour Party proposing censure instead.
The three lawmakers performed the protest haka in November during the reading of a bill that would have redefined the Treaty of Waitangi. Signed in 1840 between the British crown and Māori chiefs, the treaty established British governance and structures to protect Māori rights, and it continues to influence policy today.
The legislation was brought by the small libertarian party ACT New Zealand, which said the treaty had been misinterpreted to give Māori people special treatment.
Critics of the bill, which was defeated in April, said it would undo decades of progress for Māori, who make up about 20% of New Zealand’s 5 million people and fare worse than the rest of the population in health, education and the criminal justice system.
FOR SUBSCRIBERSA harrowing ordeal aboard an Israel-bound plane
FOR SUBSCRIBERSThe debate over AI’s future rages on both coasts
One of the Māori lawmakers, Maipi-Clarke, led the haka by tearing up a copy of the bill, joined by other Māori members and some visitors in the public gallery. Video of the protest went viral and gathered hundreds of millions of views across social media.
FOR SUBSCRIBERSA harrowing ordeal aboard an Israel-bound plane
FOR SUBSCRIBERSThe debate over AI’s future rages on both coasts
Some lawmakers objected to the way their Māori colleagues advanced toward them across the floor.
“This was a very serious incident, the likes of which I have never seen before in my 23 years in the debating chamber,” said Judith Collins of the center-right National Party, chair of the parliamentary committee that issued the report.
She added that the lawmakers performed the haka without permission and that the disruption suspended legislative proceedings for 30 minutes.
The three Māori lawmakers declined to appear before the committee during its investigation, citing disrespect for their cultural traditions. Their party said that the way it was being conducted was “grossly unjust” and that “this was not about process, this became personal.”
The committee said the lawmakers were being sanctioned not for performing the haka but for “the time at and manner in which it was performed.” It said the severity of the sanctions was intended to “leave members in no doubt that the behavior discussed is not acceptable.”
The votes had originally been scheduled for last month but were postponed so the three Māori lawmakers could participate in debate over the federal budget.
Performing the haka in Parliament is not uncommon, and it is typically seen when Māori members celebrate the passage of a particular bill. The dance is known abroad for being performed at matches by New Zealand’s rugby teams, and variations of it are also performed at funerals and formal welcomes.
“It would have been clearly understood by everyone in the Parliament that this was a peaceful act of protest done in a way that aligns with Māori tradition,” said Julian Rawiri Kusabs, a Māori historian and researcher at the University of Melbourne in Australia.
Kusabs said the suspension was a setback in decades of reconciliation efforts between the New Zealand government and Māori communities, whose members have had to navigate “a highly complex and frequently painful relationship” even to achieve representation in Parliament.
The suspension, he said, reinforces the long-standing perception that “Māori culture is not equally respected within New Zealand’s formal institutions of governance.”
