Steve Kornacki: Waiting on Alaska
In this scenario, Republicans lose seats in the midterms as voters look for a check on an unpopular president. Texas elects a Democratic senator for the first time since 1988. Former Democratic Sen. Sherrod Brown reclaims a Senate seat in Ohio, and North Carolina flips for the Democrats, too. But control of the Senate hangs in the balance as we wait for Alaska mail ballots to come in from around the rural state and be tabulated — a process that can take days.
If incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan triumphs, Republicans keep control of the Senate, with Vice President JD Vance as the tiebreaking vote. A victory for former Democratic Rep. Mary Peltola, on the other hand, would tip the balance for Democrats.
Steve Kornacki: Michigan thwarts Democratic hopes
Broad Democratic gains across the map in North Carolina, Ohio, Texas and Alaska provide a strong midterm mandate for the party. But the progressive campaign of Democrat Abdul El-Sayed falls short in battleground Michigan, and voters elect Republican Mike Rogers as their next senator, thwarting a chance for Democrats to control the Senate.
Republicans keep their majority, albeit narrowly, with Vice President JD Vance serving as the tiebreaking vote.
Kristen Welker: Democrats notch a narrow win
A narrow Democratic majority would involve Democrats holding their current battlegrounds in Georgia and Michigan, and flipping four GOP-held seats while falling short in some deeply Republican states. In this scenario, Democrats flip Maine, the one Senate seat held by a Republican in a state Trump lost in 2024, and North Carolina, the closely divided battleground state.
Under this scenario, Democrats would pick up two more seats in Republican-leaning states where the individual candidates have defined the contours of the race — Ohio, where former Democratic Sen. Sherrod Brown is looking to make a comeback, and Texas, where Republican Ken Paxton is trying to unite Republicans who did not support him in the primary.
Kristen Welker: GOP control
Republicans could hang on to the narrowest of majorities even if Democrats flip a few seats. Say Democrats are able to flip North Carolina, Maine and Ohio, and each party holds on to its other battleground states. That would result in a 50-50 Senate, giving Republicans control since Vice President JD Vance casts tiebreaking votes in the chamber.
In a tied Senate, both parties would enter a power-sharing agreement, evenly dividing committee membership, and a single senator could have enormous sway. If this happens, keep an eye on Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, who recently suggested he could rethink his status as a Democrat, saying at the Texas Tribune Festival, “Let’s revisit after the midterm and see what happens if I happen to be 51.”
Kristen Welker: Republicans grow their majority
Democrats may have the momentum, but this scenario is an important reminder of how the path to the Senate runs through some very Republican territory. In this case, Republicans hang on in red states like Iowa, Ohio and Texas, while GOP incumbent Sen. Susan Collins once again overcomes political headwinds. And while Democrats win in North Carolina, Republicans capitalize on the open seats in Michigan and New Hampshire.
Kristen Welker: Democrats dominate
A blockbuster night for Democrats would involve flipping multiple seats in deeply Republican states and holding on to their battleground seats in Michigan and Georgia. In a favorable environment, Democrats would flip Maine, the only Republican-held seat in a state that Trump lost in 2024, and North Carolina, a closely divided state.
Democrats would also pick up Alaska and Texas. And several Republicans would lose in the heartland, where farmers have struggled with tariffs and high diesel prices, including Ohio, Iowa, Kansas and Nebraska. But a Republican loss in Nebraska wouldn’t necessarily be a Democratic win — independent Dan Osborn has said he would not caucus with either party.