WILMINGTON, Del. — It was November when the word "ascertainment" entered the political lexicon as the bureaucratic barrier for Joe Biden's ability to formally begin his transition. But the word had been a front-of-center concern for months for his under-the-radar planning team, so much so that in late June its executive director, Yohannes Abraham, emailed an outside expert requesting a full briefing about the potential ramifications — and began developing a game plan for how the Biden team could move ahead without it.
The ascertainment question, which wasn't until three weeks after Election Day, was just one of several potential barriers Biden's team had to consider. Members referred to them as the "extraordinary challenges" — largely, but not exclusively, Trump-related headaches that would have to be addressed if the already-daunting task of standing up an administration in just 11 weeks would have any chance of success.
But against those odds, when Biden takes the oath in two days, he will have an administration with more key positions filled than some of his recent predecessors had and a policy process ready to tackle the multiple challenges he will face.
"Very few people do rigorous contingency planning, just because there's already enough to do, and why stare into scenarios that could make it more difficult? But lo and behold, we were ready," said Jeffrey Zients, one of the earliest hires Biden made for his transition team 10 months ago, who in turn quickly tapped Abraham as his executive director.
FOR SUBSCRIBERSA harrowing ordeal aboard an Israel-bound plane
FOR SUBSCRIBERSThe debate over AI’s future rages on both coasts
Jake Sullivan, Biden's choice for national security adviser, said, "He was essentially orchestrating that series of plays to get past the early obstruction."
Even when most agencies did begin meeting with Biden representatives, known as Agency Review Teams, the Defense Department and the Office of Management and Budget — two of the most critical — were outliers. While Abraham worked quietly to address that with his White House counterpart, Christopher Liddell, he also launched a public offensive to build pressure on the White House.
In a briefing with reporters, the low-key Abraham, 35, used what for him counted as unusually spicy language: He blasted the "pockets of recalcitrance" that were standing in the way of the kind of smooth transition the country needed and that were potentially putting America's security at risk.
"The thing about Yo is he's good at designing plays, but he's also good at running them," Sullivan said. While cooperation with defense officials is still not where it should be, Sullivan said, it's "substantially greater than it was before, in no small measure because he took a hard-headed, relentless approach."
The uneven cooperation from the Trump administration was hardly the only hurdle for Biden's team. It also had to adapt its entire approach to comply with stringent Covid-19 protocols — one of several factors, including the ascertainment delay in releasing taxpayer funds, that required it to ramp up private fundraising to set a record for any transition committee.
The initial 10,000-square-foot workspace that was provided in September, as well as the larger, 175,000-square-foot space it got post-ascertainment, largely went unused. Full-time paid staffers and volunteers worked largely from home.
Once they were authorized to do so, Agency Review Teams held more than 5,000 meetings with federal agencies and congressional officials. A team of 200 staff members and volunteers interviewed more than 7,500 people to fill thousands of administration jobs — and it had a plan in place to begin identifying and vetting personnel even without the federal resources that later came in to support them.
Through Sunday, Biden had nominated 44 Senate-confirmed officials — besting Barack Obama's mark by the same point in his transition, which had been the most recent high. The transition has also announced 206 White House staff members — more than the last three incoming presidents combined.
A particular focus of the transition team was positions that don't require Senate confirmation — from the director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to department chiefs of staff, general counsels and chief operating officers who are essential to laying the groundwork for quick action. David Marchick, director of the Center for Presidential Transition at the Partnership for Public Service, a good-government nonprofit, said Biden's team will have two to three times the resources that previous administrations have had in place.
"This is the most productive transition from a personnel perspective in history, despite the late start and the challenges associated with the outgoing president," Marchick said, crediting Abraham, in particular. "The degree of difficulty of any transition is very high. But this transition had the highest. You have the various crises — economic, health — and then you layer on top of that the political uncertainty with Trump."
As Biden prepares to be inaugurated, Abraham is making a transition himself — to his role as chief of staff for the National Security Council. Several Biden officials said Abraham's work on the transition led to something of a bidding war among principals to bring him on for a number of different agency roles.
FOR SUBSCRIBERSA harrowing ordeal aboard an Israel-bound plane
FOR SUBSCRIBERSThe debate over AI’s future rages on both coasts
It was the same nearly a year ago, when Jen O'Malley Dillon, who took over as Biden's campaign manager in March, tried to bring Abraham on in a senior role.
Abraham stayed with the fledgling transition, however, developing a routine with Zients that became the basis for work moving forward. Each week began by identifying goals and reviewing closely monitored performance metrics from the previous week, from staff recruitment and fundraising to diversity.
Abraham's responsibilities multiplied after the election, particularly once Zients was appointed to oversee the Biden administration's pandemic response. In addition to managing the day-to-day transition activities, he was part of a team interviewing Cabinet and sub-Cabinet appointees, meeting with lawmakers and outside stakeholders to incorporate their priorities and suggestions.
The transition team's success in filling most key West Wing positions, officials said, has been critical to launching an ambitious first-week policy push. Naming many top aides — Ron Klain as chief of staff, Susan Rice to lead the Domestic Policy Council, Brian Deese to lead the National Economic Council, Sullivan to head the National Security Council, Gina McCarthy to lead the climate task force and Zients as head of the Covid-19 response team — shifted most, but not all, of the burden from the transition team to those officials to build on the planning already in place.
Download the NBC News app for breaking news and politics
That was a lesson learned from previous transitions: minimize the typical conflicts between the campaign and the transition first and then between the transition and the administration to ensure that Biden's team is faithful to what the campaign promised.
"We're obviously operating in a highly uncertain moment and a crisis moment from the perspective of the economy, and so having this transition policy team in place with the breadth and the dynamism they have is absolutely essential to us being able to operate effectively. And that is a credit to the structure in the process that Yo and Jeff and the team built," Deese said.
While officials credited Abraham with building what one called a "technological marvel" to monitor progress toward completing countless tasks, Abraham never managed to plug in his only television at home — a purposeful way of staying away from cable chatter and setting a tone more broadly to keep transition team members' heads down and focus on the task at hand.
"All of this work behind the scenes of hiring people, interviewing people, getting policy processes ready — it's not as sexy," said Jen Psaki, the incoming White House press secretary. "But what worked for the campaign and what I think is working for the transition is we're just going to do our business, and we're keeping the noise out. And I think that's part of the tone that's set in the morning meetings and in our evening wraps."
