Israeli doctors confront a ‘heated question’ after Hamas attack: Would you treat a terrorist?

Catch up with NBC News Clone on today's hot topic: Israeli Doctors Confront Heated Question Hamas Attack Treat Terrorist Rcna120047 - Breaking News | NBC News Clone. Our editorial team reformatted this story for clarity and speed.

After video of a hospital confrontation stoked debate, there were mixed feelings among patients and medical workers who spoke to NBC News in Tel Aviv on Thursday.
Rockets launched from Gaza to Israel's Ashkelon city
Injured people are transferred to hospitals after Hamas launched rockets into Ashkelon, Israel, on Tuesday. Mostafa Alkharouf / Anadolu via Getty Images

TEL AVIV — Facing an unprecedented crisis after the stunning Hamas attack, Israel's doctors and nurses are now also embroiled in a "heated" debate: Would they — and should they — "treat terrorists?"

After reports spread that injured Hamas militants had been admitted to public hospitals to be treated alongside injured Israeli civilians, video emerged of dozens of angry people gathering at the entrance of one hospital in the country's south. The incident, based on unverified rumors, spread widely across social media in a reflection of a broader national discussion.

At a hospital in the Israeli city of Tel Aviv, there were mixed feelings among patients and medical workers who spoke to NBC News on Thursday — the sixth day of war between the country and Hamas.

Follow live updates from NBC News here.

"Among staff, it's a very heated subject," said Dr. Jacob Ablin, head of internal medicine at the Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center. "For some people, emotions are going, running very high and a lot of people would feel very angry and not want to treat terrorists," he added.

As for him, Ablin, 59, said there was "no question" about whether he would treat a Hamas militant. "It's like a no-brainer as far as I'm concerned. This is what we do. This is my profession."

'It's not my job to punish people'

If he did have to treat a militant, Ablin said it would not be his first time, as he has already had to do so during his military service as a doctor in the Israeli army. “It never was a question. It’s just what you do,” he said.

"It's not my job to punish people. I think those people should be punished in the harshest way possible, but not by me," Ablin said.

"It's a very heated subject," said Dr. Jacob Ablin, head of internal medicine at the Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center.
"It's a very heated subject," said Dr. Jacob Ablin, head of internal medicine at the Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center.Chantal Da Silva

Ablin made the comments from the parking lot of the medical facility, which workers have rushed to transform into an "underground hospital." The work is intended to protect patients from potential rocket attacks in the midst of the ongoing violence since Hamas launched its attack on Saturday.

So far, at least 1,300 Israelis, including 222 soldiers, have died, and in Gaza at least 1,400 people have been killed. As the war entered its sixth day, Hamas fired a new barrage of rockets toward Tel Aviv, while Israel continued to launch airstrikes on the Gaza Strip.

With emotions running high throughout Israel, video shared on social media Wednesday showed a sizable group of protesters arriving at the entrance to the Sheba Medical Center in Ramat Gan, near Tel Aviv, and walking around. Israeli media reports attributed the disturbance to a high-profile group of soccer hooligans, but NBC News has not verified the reports.

Israeli police said in a statement that three rioters were arrested at the facility. "A number of citizens arrived at the medical center and began to disturb the order there, shouting and blatantly disturbing the medical staff."

"The police declared an illegal assembly and began to evict the violators by force. Three suspects were arrested for disorderly conduct, resisting arrest and possession of a knife," authorities said.

Ablin said he had heard the news about a large group protesting outside a hospital, calling it a “very violent incident.”

A task for the national prison system

Dr. Ronni Gamzu, CEO of the Sheba Medical Center, said no Hamas militants were being treated at the facility and he noted that if any Hamas militants did need to be treated, they would be expected to receive medical care within the national prison system, rather than at local hospitals in Israel.

"This is not new," he said of the protocol, adding that the national prison service has "for years" had the infrastructure to provide medical care for those in its custody.

Still, Gamzu said that if the hospital was ever asked to treat Hamas militants, "we know what our role is ... we are doing what we need to do."

Still, in the wake of Wednesday's incident, the under-fire government responded.

Israeli media reported that the country's health minister, Moshe Arbel, had written a letter to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu informing him that he had directed all public hospitals to send any injured Hamas fighters to military or prison service medical facilities.

A spokesperson for Arbel's office did not immediately respond to a request for comment from NBC News.

'I'm not sure what the answer is'

While some health providers feel it would be their duty to provide medical care to whoever needs it, Dr. Amy Isenberg said that, for her, it was a “hard question, especially now.”

“I’m not sure what the answer is when you come face to face with it,” said Isenberg, a resident physician in the internal medicine ward at Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center.

Patients and their families at the hospital also weighed in, with some expressing outrage at the idea of any Israeli hospital treating a Hamas militant.

Adnan Aboubaker, 71, who was hospitalized after having a fall, lies on his hospital bed at the Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center on Thursday.
Adnan Aboubaker, 71, who was hospitalized after having a fall, lies on his hospital bed at the Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center on Thursday.Chantal Da Silva

"No," Adnan Aboubaker, 71, who was hospitalized after having a fall unrelated to the Hamas attack, said sternly, slicing the air with his hand in a gesture that emphasized his opposition to the mere idea.

Another man, who did not want to be named and whose son was hospitalized for a medical condition, said that he wanted Hamas militants to die — not receive treatment in an Israeli hospital.

Marina Izmailov, 34, who was in the hospital after she was injured on Saturday when an air strike hit her home in Tel Aviv, leveling her apartment building, said she didn't want to comment on the issue.

She said that despite what happened to her, she didn't feel anger.

"I could be angry about what's happened to me, but it's so much bigger than that," she said.

AdBlock Detected!
Please disable it to support our content.
×

Related Articles

Donald Trump Presidency Updates - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Joe Biden Campaign News - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Kamala Harris Vp Announcement - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Trump Indictment Latest - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Election Results Live - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Swing States Polling - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Debate Highlights - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Budget Approval 2025 - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Abortion Ruling - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Us China Relations - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Inflation Rates 2025 Analysis - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Federal Reserve Interest Rates - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Stock Market Today - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Recession Prediction 2025 - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Jobs Report Unemployment - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Ai Stock Surge - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Housing Market Crash - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Oil Prices Update - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Amazon Prime Sales - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Bitcoin Etf Approval - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Latest Vaccine Developments - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Covid Variants Update - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Boosters New Guidelines - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Anxiety Depression Treatment - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Longevity Research - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Diet Trends 2025 - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Workout Routines - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Fda Approvals 2025 - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Ukraine Russia Conflict Updates - World News | NBC News Clone | Israel Palestine War News - World News | NBC News Clone | China Taiwan Tensions - World News | NBC News Clone | Middle East Peace Talks - World News | NBC News Clone | European Union Politics - World News | NBC News Clone | Development News - World News | NBC News Clone | North Korea Missile Test - World News | NBC News Clone | Brazil Election - World News | NBC News Clone | Openai Chatgpt News - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Google Bard Ai - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Ai Regulation Laws - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Tiktok Ban Update - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Data Breaches 2025 - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Iphone 16 Release - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Nasa Mars Mission - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Web3 Developments - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | 2024 Paris Games Highlights - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | Super Bowl 2025 Preview - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | Nba Playoffs 2025 - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | Champions League Finals - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | World Series 2025 - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | Masters Tournament 2025 - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | Extreme Weather Events - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Hurricane Season 2025 - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Global Warming Report - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Weekly Weather Update - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Earthquake Alerts - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Solar Storm Warning - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Hollywood Updates - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Oscar Nominations 2025 - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Grammy Awards 2025 - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Netflix New Releases - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Video Game Releases - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Bestseller List - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Government Transparency - Investigations and Analysis | NBC News Clone | Political Corruption - Investigations and Analysis | NBC News Clone | Big Tech Monopoly - Investigations and Analysis | NBC News Clone | Data Privacy Scandal - Investigations and Analysis | NBC News Clone | Community Stories - Local News and Communities | NBC News Clone | Nyc Mayor News - Local News and Communities | NBC News Clone | La Wildfires Update - Local News and Communities | NBC News Clone | Hurricane Preparedness - Local News and Communities | NBC News Clone