CHICAGO — A federal judge in Chicago questioned immigration authorities Monday about whether they violated a court order by continuing to use tear gas and violent tactics against protesters and journalists in the area.
U.S. District Judge Sara Ellis of the Northern District of Illinois previously ruled that immigration agents were not allowed to use tear gas on journalists and protesters who pose no threat — yet the incidents have continued, drawing a rebuke from Ellis. She has also ordered that federal agents wear and use their body cameras.
Immigration enforcement has surged in the Chicago area as part of Operation Midway Blitz, which the Department of Homeland Security said last week has led to more than 1,500 arrests across Illinois. DHS did not immediately respond to request for comment about the hearing.
The judge asked Kyle C. Harvick, a Customs and Border Protection official who testified first Monday, about the CBP agents’ responsibilities, how her previous order disseminated and what training officers have received. She also asked him about specific incidents in which she had concerns about CBP’s tactics, NBC Chicago reported.
“I have a few concerns that the TRO wasn’t being followed,” Ellis said, referring to her previous temporary restraining order.
Harvick testified that there were more than 230 CBP officers in the Chicago area and that some were leaving the area Tuesday, dropping the number to about 200.
All of the agents in the Chicago area now have body-worn cameras, said Harvick, who is the CBP deputy incident commander. About 100 of them have been trained in crowd control.
Harvick said agents get training in use of physical force, batons, pepper ball launchers and chemical agents such as tear gas. He said CBP policy is to warn a crowd before tear gas is used. “I have spoken to my agents. And a warning is given before you deploy gas,” he said.
Scenes of federal agents detaining people around the city, sometimes using force, have led to an increase in demonstrations against President Donald Trump in Chicago. Community members have formed groups to monitor activity by Immigration and Customs Enforcement and Customs and Border Protection in what they say is an attempt to protect their city from government overreach.
The confrontations have escalated, with instances of federal agents using tear gas in Chicago neighborhoods.
Ellis asked Monday about several instances in which tear gas was deployed after her order restraining its use.
The CBP official said that a warning was given before it was used and that it was necessary because a crowd had gathered and linked arms, blocking its vehicle from leaving. He said that he reviewed body camera video of the incident and that he does not believe it violated the judge’s order.
Days after Ellis’ Oct. 9 order restricting the use of chemical agents on protesters and journalists, federal agents used “crowd control measures” to disperse a group of people in Chicago’s Southeast Side, according to a statement from a CBP spokesperson. NBC Chicago reported that tear gas was used on crowds that had gathered after a collision between a Border Patrol vehicle and a car the agents were pursuing. CBP said the crowd turned “hostile.”
“This type of escalation is going to cause harm. It’s not the people of Chicago — it is the federal agents,” said Beatriz Ponce De Leon, Chicago’s deputy mayor for immigration and refugee rights, NBC Chicago reported.
Ellis asked about the incident Monday. Harvick said that after the scene in which agents collided with the car, a crowd of “more and more people started to come” and some allegedly threw objects at the officers, with one agent being struck by an egg.
Harvick said the agency gave lawful orders for the crowd to move back, which were disobeyed. He added that the crowd also caused damage such as slashed tires and broken windows on other vehicles. He said tear gas was deployed three times and argued that the incident was justified given the circumstances.
The lawsuit first came in response to multiple confrontations in late September and October around an ICE processing facility in suburban Broadview, where federal agents fired pepper balls and tear gas and used force, including slamming people to the ground, as protesters tried to block vehicles from entering and leaving the facility.
Journalists and protesters filed the lawsuit on Oct. 6 to restrain federal agents’ ability to use excessive force and retaliatory tactics. The plaintiffs claimed the actions illegally restricted the First Amendment right to peacefully assemble and gather news.
Last week, DHS said on social media that its enforcement surge in the area “is making Illinois SAFE again” and that it had arrested numerous criminals and gang members. It has also said its officers are being targeted.
Ellis said last week that she had been a “little startled” after having seen images of clashes between agents and the public in the Chicago area.
DHS is also asking for modifications and exceptions to the judge’s order on body-worn cameras.
On Friday, Ellis ordered the interim head of the Chicago regional ICE field office, Russell Hott, to appear in court for the 10:30 a.m. hearing. He then abruptly returned to Washington the same day.
DHS spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement Monday that Hott had been the interim field office director in Chicago but had now returned to Washington, as planned, for his permanent post as field office director of the nation’s capital. Samuel Olson will now be the interim field office director in Chicago, she said.
DHS asked Friday to send Harvick to appear instead because, according to the Justice Department, Border Patrol officers — not ICE agents — are “mostly, if not entirely,” responsible for the recent tear gas incidents, according to WTTW, the public television station in Chicago.
“We’re not on the border. We are in an urban, densely populated area where crowds are going to converge when there’s a commotion, where appropriate crowd control is important,” Ellis said at an emergency hearing Thursday, WTTW reported. “Trying to apprehend and detain people is very, very different when you’re in an urban setting than when you’re out on the border.”
Ellis also responded Friday to the government’s request to send a different official. “If the witness says ‘I don’t know’ or can’t answer my questions, we will come in Tuesday with a different person to answer questions,” she said, adding that she wasn’t trying to “micromanage” that decision, according to NBC Chicago.
Last week, Justice Department attorney Sean Skedzielewski said “one-sided and selectively edited media reports” were to blame for the images of the violent clashes.
Daniella Silva reported from New York and Bennett Haeberle from Chicago.
