Coronavirus upends justice system as states close courts and halt trials

This version of Coronavirus Upends Justice System States Close Courts Halt Trials N1160961 - Breaking News | NBC News Clone was adapted by NBC News Clone to help readers digest key facts more efficiently.

"The ramifications could be catastrophic if not managed properly," a defense lawyer said.
Robert Durst attends a motions hearing on capital murder charges in the death of Susan Berman with attorney Dick DeGuerin in Los Angeles
Robert Durst at a hearing on capital murder charges in the death of Susan Berman in Los Angeles in January. His trial has been delayed. Mark Boster / Reuters pool file

In Los Angeles, the highly anticipated murder trial of real estate heir Robert Durst has been delayed — along with all other criminal and civil trials.

In Cleveland, judges are holding mass bail and plea hearings to reduce the number of people at risk of falling ill while behind bars.

In New Jersey, all new trials have been suspended, and municipal courts have been closed.

In Washington, D.C., the Supreme Court has postponed oral arguments, including its plans to hear a case involving President Donald Trump's efforts to block release of his tax returns.

Across the country, attempts to slow the spread of the deadly coronavirus have thrown the criminal justice system into disarray as officials try to limit large courthouse gatherings, including juries, while also making sure that people accused of crimes aren't deprived of their due-process rights.

Concerns about the outbreak seem to have hit a tipping point, with 27 states under orders to stop jury trials or restrict the number of people who can come to court, according to data collected by the National Center for State Courts as of Monday afternoon.

Some federal courts, including districts in New York and Washington, have also postponed trials.

"The only time we've heard of anything vaguely like this was after 9/11 or a hurricane, but that was only for a few days," said Bill Raftery, a spokesman for the center.

Full coverage of the coronavirus outbreak

The number of such orders is expected to continue rising in response to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's recommendation Sunday to avoid gatherings of more than 50 people, Raftery said.

On Monday, Trump recommended avoiding gatherings of 10 or more people.

While many aspects of the criminal justice system can be put off, others cannot, such as bail hearings, juvenile detention hearings, requests for temporary restraining orders in domestic violence cases and attempts to remove abused children from their homes. Laws granting defendants the right to a speedy trial generally have provisions that account for emergencies that made quick proceedings impossible, experts said.

Bail has become a particular focus of concern, because of the high risk of spreading the virus in jails.

A small number of jurisdictions have sought to reduce the number of people held in jail before trial. They include Cuyahoga County, Ohio, which includes Cleveland, where judges are holding special sessions to send more defendants home or to negotiate plea deals. In Philadelphia, District Attorney Larry Krasner said he is considering whether to allow more people to be granted bail. San Francisco District Attorney Chesa Boudin is reported to have told his prosecutors not to oppose motions to release people facing low-level charges.

In other jurisdictions, judges are conducting more bail hearings over video links to keep defendants from congregating in court.

Download the NBC News app for full coverage of the coronavirus outbreak

Norman Reimer, executive director of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, said he hoped the crisis would "accelerate the discussion about mass incarceration and the need to find ways to have fewer people imprisoned."

In the meantime, Reimer said, there is no clear sense in most jurisdictions of how they would deal with an outbreak behind bars. An inmate at the jail in Nassau County, New York, is reported to have tested positive for the coronavirus, and an employee of the New York City Department of Correction has died, officials said Monday. In both cases, officials said they were tracking who had been in touch with the infected people and working to contain the virus' spread.

Health experts say an outbreak in a jail or a prison is a question of when, not if.

"The ramifications could be catastrophic if not managed properly," Reimer said.

Duffie Stone, president of the National District Attorneys Association, said it was impossible to assess the impact of stripping the court system down to its necessary services, because there is no end in sight. He said he hoped the postponements wouldn't last longer than a month or so, but even that would cause delays to ripple through the system for much longer.

"I don't think anyone knows what the end result of this will be," said Stone, who is a prosecutor in South Carolina. "But nobody really has a choice."

AdBlock Detected!
Please disable it to support our content.
×

Related Articles

Donald Trump Presidency Updates - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Joe Biden Campaign News - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Kamala Harris Vp Announcement - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Trump Indictment Latest - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Election Results Live - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Swing States Polling - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Debate Highlights - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Budget Approval 2025 - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Abortion Ruling - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Us China Relations - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Inflation Rates 2025 Analysis - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Federal Reserve Interest Rates - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Stock Market Today - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Recession Prediction 2025 - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Jobs Report Unemployment - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Ai Stock Surge - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Housing Market Crash - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Oil Prices Update - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Amazon Prime Sales - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Bitcoin Etf Approval - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Latest Vaccine Developments - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Covid Variants Update - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Boosters New Guidelines - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Anxiety Depression Treatment - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Longevity Research - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Diet Trends 2025 - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Workout Routines - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Fda Approvals 2025 - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Ukraine Russia Conflict Updates - World News | NBC News Clone | Israel Palestine War News - World News | NBC News Clone | China Taiwan Tensions - World News | NBC News Clone | Middle East Peace Talks - World News | NBC News Clone | European Union Politics - World News | NBC News Clone | Development News - World News | NBC News Clone | North Korea Missile Test - World News | NBC News Clone | Brazil Election - World News | NBC News Clone | Openai Chatgpt News - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Google Bard Ai - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Ai Regulation Laws - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Tiktok Ban Update - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Data Breaches 2025 - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Iphone 16 Release - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Nasa Mars Mission - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | Web3 Developments - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | 2024 Paris Games Highlights - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | Super Bowl 2025 Preview - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | Nba Playoffs 2025 - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | Champions League Finals - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | World Series 2025 - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | Masters Tournament 2025 - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | Extreme Weather Events - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Hurricane Season 2025 - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Global Warming Report - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Weekly Weather Update - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Earthquake Alerts - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Solar Storm Warning - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Hollywood Updates - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Oscar Nominations 2025 - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Grammy Awards 2025 - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Netflix New Releases - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Video Game Releases - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Bestseller List - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Government Transparency - Investigations and Analysis | NBC News Clone | Political Corruption - Investigations and Analysis | NBC News Clone | Big Tech Monopoly - Investigations and Analysis | NBC News Clone | Data Privacy Scandal - Investigations and Analysis | NBC News Clone | Community Stories - Local News and Communities | NBC News Clone | Nyc Mayor News - Local News and Communities | NBC News Clone | La Wildfires Update - Local News and Communities | NBC News Clone | Hurricane Preparedness - Local News and Communities | NBC News Clone