Italian bars, restaurants decry smoking ban

NBC News Clone summarizes the latest on: Wbna6805162 - Breaking News | NBC News Clone. This article is rewritten and presented in a simplified tone for a better reader experience.

Bar and restaurant owners are refusing to police a smoking ban when it takes effect on Monday in Italy, a country where breaking the rules is often considered a right.
A woman lights a cigarette in a bar in downtown Rome Sunday. Smokers in Italy took their last puffs in smoky bars and trattorias hours before the start of one of Europe's toughest laws against smoking in public places.
A woman lights a cigarette in a bar in downtown Rome Sunday. Smokers in Italy took their last puffs in smoky bars and trattorias hours before the start of one of Europe's toughest laws against smoking in public places.Alessandra Tarantino / AP

Bar and restaurant owners are refusing to police a smoking ban when it takes effect on Monday in Italy, a country where breaking the rules is often considered a right.

The ban -- delayed for a few days so revellers could enjoy their last New Year celebrations in smoky bars -- aims to end passive smoking and deter those who choose to pursue a habit which health officials say kills 90,000 people in Italy every year.

"Those who want to smoke can do it in the street or at home but not right next to people who can't stand it and who cannot tolerate being poisoned," said the author of the new law, Health Minister Girolamo Sirchia.

"The majority of the population is tired of being poisoned by the smoke in the air where they work or where they play ... the majority, three quarters of Italians, is with us."

Mauro, an Italian smoker, begged to differ.

"It's a scandal because a government, which earns money on tax from cigarettes, can't make laws against smoking. It's like selling cars and then not allowing you to put petrol in because it pollutes - it's the same thing," he told Reuters Television.

Although smokers are in the minority -- 18 million out of a total population of 58 million -- many Italians are skeptical of a prohibition they feel smacks of American or northern European puritanism.

Ireland became the first country in the world to have a smoking ban in March 2004 but U.S. states including Maine, Florida and California and the cities of New York and Boston, have had similar bans since 2003.

The Italian law relies on bar and restaurant owners -- the vast majority of whom have not built closed off smoking rooms -- to ensure their customers do not smoke, with the threat of a fine of up to 2,000 euros ($2,646) if they do not.

But restaurant and bar owners say they refuse to be the state's sheriffs and will not call the police if their customers light up.

"Well, first of all, we aren't going to make any reports to any of the authorities. The law is a just one, but it has been introduced too quickly," Rome bar owner Paolo Rosetti said.

Rosetti and others risk being caught out by undercover police who are planning crackdowns in the early hours of Monday.

Giant cigarette in a coffin
One mournful restaurant owner in the Tuscan city of Grosetto held a mock funeral dinner. He distributed free cigarettes and cigars to customers and urged them to light up while eating.

He constructed a giant plastic cigarette and placed it in a coffin with a plaque reading "Rest in Peace-Jan 10, 2005."

"This is a real witch hunt, where the witch isn't the cigarette but is the restaurateur," said Edi Sommariva, head of the trade body FIPE which represents 240,000 bars, restaurants and nightclubs across Italy.

In Naples, famous among Italians for its anarchic spirit, a cinema let viewers in for free to a showing of the Mexican film "Nicotina," as long as they could produce a packet of cigarettes that they intended to smoke during the show.

Defense Minister Antonio Martino is used to lighting a cigarette in cabinet meetings in front of Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi whom he describes as a "tolerant non-smoker."

"After Nazism and Fascism it was Communism that fell. The concept where the state could control everything seemed to have suffered a resounding, definitive defeat, but no. Defeated on the economic front, the enemies of liberty are looking for victories in other areas," said the minister, a founding member of Berlusconi's ruling Forza Italia party.

×
AdBlock Detected!
Please disable it to support our content.

Related Articles

Donald Trump Presidency Updates - Politics and Government | NBC News Clone | Inflation Rates 2025 Analysis - Business and Economy | NBC News Clone | Latest Vaccine Developments - Health and Medicine | NBC News Clone | Ukraine Russia Conflict Updates - World News | NBC News Clone | Openai Chatgpt News - Technology and Innovation | NBC News Clone | 2024 Paris Games Highlights - Sports and Recreation | NBC News Clone | Extreme Weather Events - Weather and Climate | NBC News Clone | Hollywood Updates - Entertainment and Celebrity | NBC News Clone | Government Transparency - Investigations and Analysis | NBC News Clone | Community Stories - Local News and Communities | NBC News Clone